REVIEWS OF "IN THE MEANTIME"
"Noble is one of the younger UK pianists
most likely to turn surprising corners. A highly inventive
and thoughtful musician, Noble graces any band he joins,
while his own music combines characterful composing with
fresh, risk-embracing improvisation.... Some wonderful,
hooting, almost country-blues music balances the busyness,
and Sulzmann - superb on tenor sax throughout - has rarely
played better"
John Fordham, The Guardian 3*
Feb 2003
"The economy and spiky thoughtfulness
of Noble's piano-playing is often close to Thelonious Monk,
Andrew Hill and occasionally Abdullah Ibrahim in spirit
rather than mimicry. But, although Noble's classy quintet
kept faith with his intentions, it was the harmonic intrigue
of The Bathroom Mirror, the twisting melody and Celtic echoes
of Across the Park and the Mike Gibbs-like horn harmonies
of a closing almost-blues that made Noble's wry, pungent
writing the star".
John Fordham, The Guardian May
2002 -Review of Cheltenham Festival
"Collaboration of reeds players Stan
Sulzmann and Chris Biscoe, pianist Liam Noble, bassist Mick
Hutton and drummer Paul Clarvis proves that the spirit of
free improvisation is not dead, but has been merely sleeping.
Noble's stunning charts sit alongside an uplifting version
of Lionel Bart's "Who Will Buy?". Inspirational".
Chrissie Murray, Ronnie Scott's
Magazine
“Pianist Liam Noble has already
impressed through his work with such as Bobby Wellins, Christine
Tobin and Paul Clarvis and In the Meantime wholeheartedly
confirms that he’s a player to keep an eye on. Surrounded
by a bunch of strong if underrated personalities that include
Clarvis as well as Stan Sulzmann and Chris Biscoe, Noble
has produced one of the best independent releases that I’ve
heard of late. An elegant player with an incisive if at
times understated style, Noble excels as a writer and arranger
on this set. The themes and orchestrations – capitalising
wholeheartedly on the fine playing of the ensemble of which
Sulzmann and Biscoe stand out – are affecting and
occasionally rapturous affairs that strike an all too rare
balance between strong, strident forward drive and graceful
poise. Harmonic finesse and wily counterpoint are the order
of the day but perhaps what impresses the most is the idiomatic
range of the material that echoes of anything from Keith
Jarrett and early 70’s ECM to Wayne Shorter and very
occasionally Thelonious Monk. Yet what we end up with is
nevertheless a very British sounding album – something
that would sit very well in the Babel catalogue. And the
severely reharmonised version of Lionel Bart’s ‘Who
Will Buy?’ is a delight, confirming Noble’s
ability to take a left turn all the while keeping on the
straight and narrow. All told In the Meantime is an articulate,
accomplished affair from a musician who is surely more than
ready to step out of the shadows.”
Kevin Le Gendre , Jazzwise April
2003 4 *
"This is as close as any British
composer has come to the vivid unorthodoxy of New York's
downtown scene. Heard out of context, you'd think this was
a recent outing by someone like Wayne Horvitz. The only
giveaway is that Hutton and Clavis refuse to anchor the
music in any rythmic certainty as an American section certainly
would and take it off to the very edges.
Noble is capable of quirkiness in one
measure and jaw-dropping beauty in the very next. He belongs
to a long line of English "eccentrics", which
could include anyone from Lord Berners to Lol Coxhill, who
are not so much improvisers in the conventional sense as
instant composers, musicians who fire off ideas according
to no obvious structural philosophy but with absolute self-consistency.
It's hard to exaggerate just how good this album is. Tracks
like "The Bathroom Mirror" stopped me short in
precisely that place, blade dangerously poised, while Noble
and the group executed an astonishing harmonic walkabout.
"Close Your Eyes" finds them in more conventional
jazz mode, as is perhaps appropriate at the end of the record,
a blues-tinged structure that is ineffably beautiful and
will (if Liam isn't very disciplined) end up on someone's
soundtrack one of these days. It doesn't need images, and
none of the tracks on In The Meantime needs a programme
or an explanation. Check out the superb "Across The
Park" and "Waltz" as contrasting examples
of what this group can do. Stan Sulzmann is, as ever, inspirational,
but it's Chris Biscoe who catches the ear this time round,
not least for his unexpected double on alto clarinet, a
warm-toned instrument with an unexpected Range and resonance.
Joe Lovano is the only other player I've heard recently
who gives it the same emotional colouration. This is a vintage
British jazz record and the most compelling sign yet that
Liam Noble is going to be a composer to watch and listen
to very carefully indeed".
BRIAN MORTON (The Jazz Review,
April 2003)
“Excellent set by a UK pianist who
has not only made a mark as a quirky improvioser with Monkish
leanings and as a distinctive composer, but who has also
enhanced the work of many other local players. Shades of
the Django Bates style of thematic writing can be detected
here and there in some engagingly jumpy, unjazzlike melodies,
and the dense, long-lined, dynamically restrained manner
of Greg Osby’s music is also touched on. But a shining
light of the whole attractive enterprise is the presence
of Stan Sulzmann, who seems to sound more personal and hauntingly
moving than ever. Lionel Bart’s ‘Who Will Buy?’,
sounding like a Wayne Shorter track, is an unexpected interloper
in the repertoire.” John Fordham JazzUK
"Pianist Liam Noble is one of the most distinctive
voices in British jazz, a pianist of spiky individuality
and a composer whose work consistently surprises.
Both virtues are on display here as Noble
leads a quintet through a programme of utterly distinctive
music. It's edge of the seat stuff, full of unexpected twists
and turns, and yet everything has a sense of rightness and
logic that makes it immensely satisfying to listen to.
The star of the session is that wonderful
saxophonist Stan Sulzmann, whose work on Waltz and the bluesy
Hello Boys is wonderful. Altoist and clarinettist Chris
Biscoe isn't far behind on Who Will Buy and The Bathroom
Mirror, and the exchanges between the two saxophonists are
wonderful.
Noble himself is on top form throughout,
and there is good support from bassist Mick Hutton and drummer
Paul Clarvis. Liam Noble is quietly establishing himself
as a major voice". Andrew Vine Yorkshire Post 4*
“Birmingham Conservatoire jazz piano
tutor Liam Noble was recently heard to great effect on saxophonist
Julian Siegel’s five-star album Close Up. In the leader’s
chair he takes a more adventurous path both as composer
and in choice of band members, going for the highly-individualistic
sounds of saxophonists Stan Sulzmann and Chris Biscoe, bassist
Mick Hutton and drummer Paul Clarvis.
His writing sounds are strongly influenced
by the modern black American school started by pianists
ike Andrew Hill and Muhal Richard Abrams and continued by
the M-basers Steve Coleman and greg Osby.
Noble’s style is more in the crispy
category than in the crunchy area occupied by Matthew Shipp
and Jason Moran, but like them he might feel the hand of
Thelonious Monk upon his shoulder. But he can wear his heart
on his sleeve too.
He does some very clever things with Lionel
Bart’s Who Will Buy, setting up a trance-like piano
figure for the saxophones to play across, with complementary
dry and dusty tones from Sulzmann’s saxophone and
Biscoe’s alto clarinet.
The band often straddles the line between
form and freedom, but they accomplish it all with aplomb.
And Old Masters is just lovely.Good strong stuff.”
Peter Bacon, The Birmingham Post
"Liam Noble studied music at Oxford
University, and after his postgraduate course at the Guildhall,
he became the pianist for Stan Sulzmann. Noble was recommended
by John Taylor, who had played with Sulzmann, who had played
with Kenny Wheeler, who had played with Taylor. Noble then
went on to join forces with Wheeler as well as with Lol
Coxhill and John Stevens. All of this should stand in testimony
to his skills as a piano player. That quality is underlined
on this disc, which also strongly profiles his ability as
a composer.
As a composer, Noble rows up different
streams. He does this articulately and with finesse. Helping
him translate the music into an avid listening experience
is his band; they understand and they explore, bringing
in several moments of delight and surprise. It comes in
the tangent, the slight veer away from the line, the repeated
motif or a shift in timbre, and it all leads up to anticipation
for more.
The band gives the listener the “Once Over”
steeped in the mainstream. Sulzmann lets his tenor define
the mood and then squeezes out some twisted lines. He is
high on the bounce as well, setting the tone and getting
some nice support from Clarvis on the drums. The panorama
opens to envelop Biscoe and Noble, the former coiled, the
latter transparent and lighter. One good tune deserves another,
and as they go traipsing “Across the Park” they
bring in a rhythm that shifts, meter and pulse in flux until
they all lock in to form kaleidoscopic melodic patterns.
The blues come in through “The Bathroom Mirror,”
beautifully structured and played with beguiling warmth.
And they don't forget to add a supple beat either.
There are no diminishing returns here
(except for that song title) which quite simply means that
this is an absorbing album".
Jerry D'Souza AllAboutJazz.com
"Flugelhorn maestro Harry Beckett
has spent 40 years pursuing his own idiosyncratic approach
to jazz phrasing and tonality. This gig with his usual band
(with the addition of Liam Noble on piano) proved that he
isn't about to change now. There were the usual stuttering
exclamations, tightly clipped splutters and messy note smears,
and the contrasting fast flurries that make him sound as
if he were trying to blow dust from his horn.
Beckett's approach is an acquired taste,
made easier to swallow by the free-flowing lyricism of his
bandmates. Saxophonist Chris Biscoe used the opening tune,
Spiral Feelings, to showcase a Sonny Rollins-like approach
to improvisation, setting long, swooping blues lines against
agile scrambles. During the opening to the tune Forgive
and Forget, his elegant theme seemed to be suffering deliberate
sabotage from Beckett, who buffeted it with abrasive interjections
and ragged phrasing.
In electric bassist Fred T Baker and drummer
Tony Marsh, Beckett has a rhythm section that sounds like
an inspired collision of Jaco Pastorius and Paul Motian.
Marsh provided a relentless, forward-driving pulse without
ever seeming to lead the groove with a particular hand or
foot. During his solo, he used dense thickets of cymbals
and swirling concentric tom-tom patterns to imitate a herd
of musical elephants let loose in a grandfather-clock shop.
But the revelation was Liam Noble, a musician
who just keeps getting better. On the piano he provided
rhapsodic chordal work, gospel-inspired fervour and pentatonic
splatters that recalled Mike
Garson's work on David Bowie's Aladdin Sane. He also joined
Baker and Marsh in some softly glowing trio passages that
provided a welcome respite from all the crashing and banging.
Their leader may
occasionally sound like a crabby caricature of himself,
but his band is an impressively versatile unit".
James Griffiths Monday April 4,
2005 The Guardian